Showing posts with label review. Show all posts
Showing posts with label review. Show all posts

Tuesday, 25 March 2008

Great Poets of the Twentieth Century: No. 3 - Sylvia Plath

There are two things that it is almost impossible to avoid mentioning when writing about Sylvia Plath, a fact which tends to constrict discussion of her work. As a result, Plath tends to be treated as a tragedy or a battleground, rather than a poet. This is unfortunate not just because it gets boring, but because it distracts from her work.

And what visceral, unsettling, forceful poetry it is. Plenty of poets turn up the emotional volume or try to unsettle the reader: for all the familiarity that comes with her work's fame, Plath is still unique as a poet who can make me feel physically sick with the strength of what she's writing. Margaret Drabble's comment that she wrote from the body (like her striking opening that 'Sylvia Plath was the first poet to write great poetry about childbirth') is an important observation. She also forces the reader to read from the body, as well. The images are physical and immediate and connected by emotional associations rather than cool logic. (Icy logic, sometimes, yes). It is unfortunately that the term has been so misused (and associated with negative overtones) because her poetry is, in a real sense, hormonal: the all-encompassing emotional response of the body's most forceful way of communicating with itself.

Everything is focussed on maximising her impact: her stripped, pounding verse forms, her reuse of striking imagery, the preponderance of imagery in general. And also, a disturbing habit of using race and racism for shock value. This can leave a nasty taste, for example when in Daddy she identifies with Jews using the most startling stereotypes ('with my gipsy ancestress and my weird luck / And my Taroc pack and my Taroc pack / I may be a bit of a Jew'). It's not just T S Eliot who can engage in racial stereotyping, it seems. It should be seen as a part of her method, however. Showing a lack of empathy, yes, but race is used as another shocking image to convey her own emotional horror.

This is just one more way in which her work feels radioactive: energetic, powerful, a defining force of the mid-century and subject to mathematically strict laws of decay. As Beckett said about Joyce's Finnegans Wake:
Here words are not the polite contortions of 20th century printer's ink. They are alive. They elbow their way on to the page, and glow and blaze and fade and disappear.

Sunday, 23 March 2008

Great Poets of the Twentieth Century: No. 2 - W H Auden

I had an odd experience with Auden once. Recommended him by a friend with dependable taste, I took his Collected Shorter Poems with me on an eight-week holiday as the only poetry I packed. (You can imagine the airport security: 'Careful, this one's packin' some poetry'). Anyhow, after detailed rereading of the book I was impressed in parts, but puzzled at my friend's enthusiasm. I challenged him about it on my return. 'Me, recommend Auden? Unlikely: I don't like it', he replied. I was, to put it mildly, even more perplexed.

This, I'm sure, is a much more straight-forward way to meet Mr Auden. Particularly so thanks to the graceful introduction by Rowan Williams, which addresses complex and sensitive issues of politics, sexuality and religion with a light but clear touch. He's got a distinctive prose style, too: sentences with multiple clauses which often start with a parenthesis but which nonetheless are perfectly lucid. The light qualifications of his remarks seem a mark of modesty and scrupulousness, rather than obscurity.

From the outset, he makes the clearest case for Auden's distinctiveness:

'Two things often said about great poets are that they create the taste by which they are appreciated, and that they have the capacity to constantly reinvent themselves. Auden illustrates these features perhaps more dramatically than any other of the great names of the 2oth century'.

It's these, too, that make him so difficult to get a handle on.

His overwhelming importance to his contemporaries in the '30s is, to my mind, baffling. His distinctive, thoughtful, voice sounds more like that of an interesting outsider. Obviously, his form at producing startlingly resonant poems (for example Musee des Beaux Arts, included here) would push him to prominence. But arguably one of Larkin's greatest achievements was to find a way of incorporating that discursive, analytical voice of Auden's in a way that neutralised its tendency to bleach out rounded emotion when used by lesser talents.

Talent and technique are things for which Auden is regularly praised. But I'd take question with Williams' assertion that 'the technical skill is always exceptional'. His strong use of end-rhyme with lines whose meaning flows over one to another creates, to my mind, a dissonant effect: the technique is prominent, rather than deft. This can be compared to Byron, frequently Auden's model, who has true lightness of touch despite being more dazzlingly showy. Equally, the mis-placed stress in the second verse of As I Walked Out One Evening has always infuriated me:

'And down by the brimming river
I heard a lover sing
Under an arch of the railway
"Love has no ending...'

It's like a dance partner treading on your foot: 'ending'. Tsk!

There were many particular pleasures in reading this selection, however. Picking carefully back over Lullaby, I discovered that beyond it's first verse and beautiful and striking phrases ('Lay your sleeping head, my love, / human on my faithless arm', 'fashionable madmen raise / their pedantic boring cry', 'watched by every human love' etc) it does actually make a sort of sense as a whole. And Secrets and Whitsunday in Kirchsetten were both new to me (as far as I recall) and striking poems, too. The latter seems like what the American poet, Robert Lowell attempts, but done more successfully: a discursive and inclusive sensibility, taking in a wide range of subjects, voices and striking phrases and reflecting the fractured texture of post-war Europe. For that broadening of my appreciation of Auden's work, I'm grateful to this selection.

Saturday, 22 March 2008

Great Poets of the Twentieth Century: No. 1 - T S Eliot

A friend's kindly passed on this series of seven pamphlets about 'great poets' from last century and I'll be writing about each in turn. It's great to see poetry being so widely distributed and I hope it's given lots of people pleasure and encouraged them to explore further, too.

It makes sense in many ways to start with T S Eliot in the series: he's got a good claim to be the most accomplished and is surely the most influential of the poets included (although arguably it's Pound who was most influential, working through Eliot). Both The Waste Land and Four Quartets stand out among the poetry of the time and his other works on their own would be sufficient to make Eliot a significant minor poet (by his own definition). That he was also a major essayist, publisher and dramatist only adds to his lustre.

Craig Raine's introduction is curious: it's a well-turned short piece that manages to approach Eliot with a degree of freshness (no small achievement, that). It also covers a range of Eliot's aspects, from the humorous (often overlooked) to the erudite (no contradiction) to the nature poet. This latter is perhaps the most striking angle in the piece and not one I'm quite convinced by. Eliot seems to me to be someone who is highly skilled at imitating the way that poets write about nature, rather than a nature poet directly. He also uses nature to get to some other point, rather than as an object of attention of intrinsic interest. But it's true that he's very accomplished at describing it, even in passing.

However, although the introduction is interesting and fresh, it does obstruct the reader at the same time as trying to draw them in. He gets a little distracted by academic and literary historical associations (it can't be helpful to refer to which reader's guides are 'required' to read Pound and Joyce, for example). Which isn't to say that the reference points aren't exactly the right ones - but perhaps he is assuming that his readers are more comfortable with glancing references to Browning than is the case? And, unless I'm huncommonly iggorant, 'The staminate and pistillate, /Blest office of the epicene' is not exactly 'easy to appreciate'.

A couple of other provocative statements which (as he no doubt intended) it is difficult to let lie: that 'all contemporary poetry when it is contemporary is initially baffling to its readers' (I'll come back to this one separately) and this gem:

'...a postmodern poetic school led by J H Prynne whose purpose is to be difficult... (not difficult to be difficult, actually).'

I'm not sure that saying it's their purpose to be difficult is a fair characterisation (though clearly, they don't go out of their way to avoid it). But the aside in brackets is a neat point which would be usefully remembered by all of Pound's (and Eliot's) heirs. I doubt whether the heavily armoured knight of obscurity J H Prynne is likely to feel such a pin-prick, though.

But enough of Mr Raine (though he once did Eliot's former job as Editor at Faber, we should not let him occupy the great man's place here). It's an interesting and rounded selection from Eliot's work. It would have been easy to have dwelt only on the big famous poems (and they are the famous ones for a reason). But having some of the shorter, more whimsical pieces does help make sense of Eliot's style when it's in its Sunday best. Even at full pitch, he's playful and (whisper it) on occasion irrelevant (which is part of the pleasure). Apart from anything else, La Figlia Che Piange is one of the loveliest poems I know.

That said, it brings me to one particular issue (admittedly hard to avoid when selecting from Eliot): having two of the first three poems starting with an epigram in a foreign tongue is a little off-putting (perhaps a note or two would have been helpful?). I suppose that feeling of frustration that an otherwise powerfully expressive poem has been held at arms length because of a scrap of Latin is an essential part of the experience of reading Eliot for the first time. But it's not very user-friendly, particularly given the distribution through a national newspaper.

Another intriguing feature of this selection which makes good use of theguardian's involvement is the inclusion of selections from early reviews. It's amusing to hear (ok I'll say it: 'the greatest poem of the Twentieth Century': there) described as 'The Waste Land an accident in which poetry has been wounded to death'. It's illuminating too; not just in a 'ooh weren't they wrong' kind of way. Eliot and his fellow High Modernists did do a lot of damage to widespread enjoyment of poetry. Some folks just don't dig that Greek 'n' Latin vibe.

There's amusement too in the statement (just listen to all the self-satisfied and consternated undertones) 'we [sic] cannot think that an acquaintance with "The Golden Bough," Verlaine, Nerval, St Augustine, Marvell, Kyd, Virgil and Dante displays any deep erudition'. Righty-ho. Still, you'd think that if he was that well read he'd realise that Mr Eliot's not actually too shabby, all in all. Doh!

Sunday, 16 March 2008

There was Fire in Vancouver, by Sinead Morrissey

There's a poem near the end of this collection where Sinead Morrissey describes watching a juggler:

He must have practiced for hours...
...To dance the seven painted skittles
Off his fingers like that.
He has the game whittled

To art. God knows what
Anachronism he took up before...

...He knows
How we anticipate failiure...

...We are nevertheless caught

By the weightlessness, the controlled
Mechanics of air...

...We are not as far out
From faith as we were.

This filletted precis of the poem could describe Morrissey's own work. Having been so utterly impressed by her reading in Belfast, I anxiously anticipated success. Nonetheless, in the sense of practiced performance, the sense of technical accomplishment to a modestly entertaining end and the sense of someone learning a traditional skill and exploring uses for it, this poem is true to the experience of reading the book as a whole.

There's an interesting essay by Hazlitt (called The Indian Juggler) that compares juggling with art, attempting to use one to clarify the boundaries of the other. Certainly, the moments of less original proficiency give a sense of very normal poetic material being shuffled around deftly.

This is not to say that there aren't fine poems in here: Amongst Communists, Awaiting Burial and My New Angels are all well turned. And there are fine lines in others: 'The trees' bold undoing / Is no serious grief, but an accomplishment of practice' in A Performance, for example. To Look Out Once From High Windows is also an interesting comment on Larkin's loss of creativity following the poems that make up his last collection, High Windows, although one that is a little neatly comfortable to feel true of that particular case.

Overall, the book is more reminiscent of Elizabeth Jennings' little gems, such as Delay, or as prompted on the cover, the strongly placed and humane observations of RS Thomas. But it feels that she is still searching for a poetic identity and trying on a range of subject matters. In this collection the result is rather slight, though it's evident that the skill is there. I haven't lost faith, but I look forward to seeing this skill being more convincingly employed in her other collections.

Tuesday, 11 March 2008

For All We Know, by Cieran Carson

This is the first Poetry Book Society Choice I've been sent. It's a collection of 70 poems, with each half of the book having the same sequence of 35 titles. Similar subjects, images and ideas recur throughout, with associations particularly edivent in adjacent poems or between corresponding pairs: it's no wonder there are frequent references to fugue.

And yet, there's a greater sense of discursiveness and incorporating new material than is typical in fugues. This is partly because of the verse form, long unrhymed couplets. It's also because the repeated subjects (violet, watches, Bach, Berlin and Dresden, The Troubles, speaking French, Hesse's beautiful novel The Glass Bead Game, Mont Blanc pens and second hand clothes) aren't similar enough to be inversions of or variations on each other, although they do work together to create a distinctive atmosphere. Here, the doubling is used not for sharpening focus, but opening up possibilities.

A particular challenge for which work very much as a whole, like this one, is to make the individual poems well formed in themselves. Whilst it's an elegantly structured collection, it's not particularly quoteable, because each part depends on the others for its effect. There are some particular pleasures with this approach: the playful reworking of one poem in its twin, for example. This is most obvious where the Edenic Apple Mac's drop-down menus are 'putting words into your mouth' and then the corresponding poem's description of eating an apple called a Discovery. The prominence of such structures and repetitions ensures that, unlike the famous description of Hamlet as ' a play made of quotes', this is definitely a poetry collection before it is a book of poems.